I would love to give these a Great Review but they are too hard for my 10 cats. I thought they were puffed ones. They like the smell but they keep spitting them back out because they are very hard. Sorry for this review being not very good!!! Love All the Products Whole Life Pet has!!!

Do NOT BUY! They changed the recipe on these. They were a soft light treat, and now they are harder than a rock. My cat almost choked on the new ones. They are too hard, and too little!
VERY DISAPPOINTED as my cat loved the old recipe, and now I have to search, for a new gut treat. :rage:
They don’t even look like the picture on the bag.

My cat won’t touch the new formula of the healthy gut with chicken and yogurt, now that it’s been changed. Now I’m stuck with an opened and an unopened package that I can’t get my money back for as they were shipped through Amazon. I’m super bummed because my cat loved the old formula and is constantly asking for it.

My cat used to love this, but they changed their formula and now he won’t touch them. So bummed.

The new version of Living Treats Probiotic treats for cats are terrible. They are hard as rocks. The old version was a soft moist texture that was easily crumbled over their food. My cats loved them, but they won't eat these new ones. Why do these companies have to change and ruin a good product. I won't be buying them any more.

Easy treats and meal toppers for my Rottie and they aren’t high cal or with unnecessary additives. She always wants more

My three cats won’t touch these “treats”

My cats absolutely loved them. Favorite so far.

Our cat is picky, and has issues with food in general... Itchy face, runny eyes... So we are going "pure" food for her. She LOVES these. Can't comment on results or quality yet, but I can't keep her away from the bag.

My cat will sit at his bowl and meow until I add these to his food. I crush them up and sprinkle in his food and he just loves it. Nice little treat for him.

My cats love it so that is all thst matters!!

This is essentially kitty krack in our house :)

Great for my cats diagestive system great value

If you need to get your Cats to do almost anything, use the fresh frozen Salmon pieces as an incentive.My cats love them. We use them as a distraction while I administer their daily shots…insulin. They are more cooperative with this treat coming. Hope it works for you.

My cat cant get enough..loves the flavor. And it really helps his digestion,

These are lightweight with hardly any smell. My cat loves them so much that she reaches out her paw trying to grab them when she sees me pick up the bag. I'll definitely buy again.

The kitties LOVE them! I Was hesitant at first because they are so dry. I was a little scared they would choke on them. But they devour them and beg for more! Iâ€:tm:m not sure how the probiotics work, but I do see less wet poos then before - full disclosure I also changed their primary diet so I canâ€:tm:t say if it is the treats or the new food that cleared up their tummy issues, but either way I have very happy kitties

Finally , sensible packaging that doesnâ€:tm:t allow product breakage in transit

We have 8+ kitty. She is the rescue cat , found being undernourished and probably abandoned, but still sweet to humans. We noticed she doesn't drink any water. We add water in her wet food to hydrate her. However she struggles to poop too often. We used MiroLax time to time. Then we tried this product. She loves this treat crushed in her wet food. No problem with number 2 anymore. our kitty is happy, we are happy!!

Finally loves something that is healthy

Wish they were a little more flat instead of round. I cut them into smaller pieces and they just gobble them up. Thank you so much. Their poop doesn't stink and my oldest cat is able to go more easily. That's awesome.

Great way to keep some probiotics in kittys diet. She likes it and is gone in a split second. End of story!

My cat LOVES these healthy treats!

The first time I bought these and put them in front of my cats they looked up at me like I was crazy. So I thought I had bombed again with another unsuccessful cat treat, but I did try again and ever since that second time they actually really like these now. I haven't tried the chicken ones yet on them, only the salmon ones. They're pretty reasonably priced and there are a lot of them in a bag. They do look forward to having these treats everyday. I absolutely agree with one other reviewer who mentioned the shipping issues. These treats will easily get crushed into a powder. So I made a point to place a separate order this last time so that they were shipping by themselves because the first time they shipped them with a case of cat food and they were about 50% smashed to powder by the time they arrived.

It appears to be a good quality product. I will keep ordering it for my dear rescue kitty.

My cats love these things so much we keep them on hand now. I tried to subscribe and save them on Amazon because there's not a pet store that carries them convenient to home. The first pack showed up about 30% treat dust, the second pack was at least 80% treat dust.

My cats really like these treats.

My cat loves these and they are so good for him !

My cats love it, bought it for one of my cats thatâ€:tm:s been taking amoxicillin

I purchased the chicken flavor. The consistency is like a meringue. Half my cats like it and half donâ€:tm:t. Itâ€:tm:s not the manufacturerâ€:tm:s fault I think it has to do with the catsâ€:tm: food preference and psychology. The ones that didnâ€:tm:t like it, itâ€:tm:s possible that there wasnâ€:tm:t enough chicken flavoring in it that the smell wasnâ€:tm:t as attractive to them. I noticed another one of my finicky eaters she has a smaller snout, had a somewhat liking to the smaller sized pieces (she ate one). It really just depends on what youâ€:tm:re cat likes. If youâ€:tm:re curious try one bag and see. The cats I have that do like it have weird quirks like they hate canned wet food and will not touch any (safe for cats) fresh meat. They only eat and like dry food. Other than that great product for supplementing probiotic if your cat isnâ€:tm:t too picky. I think Iâ€:tm:m going to try the other flavor for them and see if that doesnâ€:tm:t resolve my picky eaters dilemma.